Thought workplace outbursts were simply about poor professionalism? 

You're not alone if you've wondered where the line is between accountability and accommodation.  

And I'll explain why this recent tribunal case should change how we think about managing employees with mental health challenges to avoid discrimination claims. 

Why Mental Health Discrimination Claims Are So Complicated for Employers 

Here's what usually happens: 

An employee has a public meltdown. Management focuses on the immediate damage to reputation.  

Management follows standard disciplinary procedures. The employee gets dismissed for gross misconduct. Then everyone assumes the case is closed. 

After two decades of employment law, here's what I know: 

Mental health doesn't excuse behaviour, but it explains it. 

I've seen that employers who ignore the underlying causes miss opportunities to prevent future incidents and discrimination tribunal claims entirely. 

Workplace Discrimination and Outbursts 

A recent tribunal case shows exactly what I mean. 

A junior chef at Thorpe Hall Leisure, an upscale spa, had a very public argument with her colleague, who also worked there. She used aggressive language that guests overheard, including some seriously inappropriate words about their failed relationship. 

Multiple guests complained. The hotel's reputation was at stake. Management acted swiftly and dismissed her for gross misconduct. 

Case closed, right? Not quite. 

The Real Story Behind the Discrimination Tribunal Case 

The tribunal revealed crucial details that changed everything. 

The chef had disclosed her ongoing struggles with anxiety and depression.  

She'd been on sick leave for mental health reasons just months earlier. Her return-to-work forms documented her medication and ongoing treatment. 

But when the incident occurred, nobody connected the dots. 

During the disciplinary hearing, she minimised what had happened, failing to acknowledge how her outburst had affected guests and colleagues. Management dismissed her and offered the standard right to appeal. 

She requested an appeal but provided no specific reasons why the decision was wrong. Then she simply didn’t show up to her appeal hearing, sealing her fate. 

The real issue wasn’t the outburst itself; it was the complete failure to consider reasonable adjustments. 

This is where many employers unknowingly cross the line into discrimination territory. 

Avoid This Expensive Discrimination Lesson

Documentation Matters More Than You Think  

Good employers keep detailed records of employee health disclosures. But great employers actually use that information when incidents occur. The tribunal specifically noted that failing to obtain a medical report was discriminatory. 

Mental Health Isn't a Free Pass, But It's Context  

The chef's behaviour was still unacceptable, the tribunal agreed with that. But her inability to control her response during the disciplinary process was directly linked to her disability. Context doesn't excuse, but it should inform your response. 

Reasonable Adjustments Aren't Just About Physical Accommodations  

Could the employer have offered additional support? Different disciplinary procedures? A mental health assessment before making the final decision? The tribunal thought so, and it cost them £13,500 in discrimination compensation. 

Reputation vs. Responsibility  

Yes, protecting your business reputation matters. But you can't ignore your legal obligations to employees with disabilities. The tribunal found both considerations valid, but only one was properly balanced. 

Here's the truth: 

You don't need to become a mental health expert to handle these situations better. You need awareness, documentation, and the wisdom to pause before making permanent decisions. 

The fact that you care about both your business and your people isn't a weakness; it's exactly what good leadership looks like. 

When It's Time to Get Professional Help 

You'll know it's time to call employment law specialists when: 

• An employee has disclosed mental health conditions 

• You're dealing with behaviour that seems out of character 

• The standard disciplinary process feels inadequate for the situation 

• You're weighing reputation concerns against legal obligations  

Every outburst has a story, and understanding that story might save you both money and heartache. 

Do you need Free Advice? Download the HR Doctor App.